How to determine if a guild member is active?

I think when people just say BUMP, the conversation is over. So instead you can bump things by adding new thoughts on a topic. In some other threads Rovio has acknowledged the trophy balancing is on their list so that should help. I think guild chat participation is obvious but when we are playing with global player, who may be ESL, they may not be as chat friendly. I hope that the suggestions made here are seen as simple requests for a better exchange of player data to help make the game more enjoyable. Hope to see some of this in the next update.

 

I used to apply a formula to the trophies, considering the contribution board by board: B1/50+B2/50+B3/3,75+B4.... I do not quite remember if I used some weapon damage or some boat mission to create the formula, but, as you can see, the fourth board was the reference.
B = trophies in a specific board
It's tough as hell to keep doing it rivalry after rivalry, I'd love if the game did that for me, but unfortunately it doesn't.

 

Thank you

 

And when again is that? Asking for a friend.

 

It's possible to apply an accurate formula, but you would have to track trophies by participant by quest by board, hundreds of data points... far too much work, so I count matches played... simple and effective... and also very manual.

Current situation:
Board 1 - 1000 trophies distributed per quest @ 1x effort
Board 2 - 1250 trophies 3x effort
Board 3 - 1500 trophies 9x effort
Board 4 - 1750 trophies 27x effort

With the detailed quest data, the formula would be dead simple... but it would be better if they matched effort

Board 1 - 100 trophies distributed per quest
Board 2 - 300
Board 3 - 900
Board 4 - 2700

Then we could finally use trophies to measure guild participation. I keep hearing guild leaders are using trophies... that needs to stop until an adjustment like this is made.

 

And how do you figure out if the players were doing missions while they were playing?
The Grim Repair's answer gave me hope they will make guild leaders' job easier