Guilds Useless ?

Okay to be fair game is new and all but if you implementing the guilds in-game shouldnt they have a purpose? I have seen lots of people dosent want to join because ther nothing do gain/do/contribute. I mean yes there could be guild wars, in-guild tournaments and etc. but Im not talking about this, yet.

So lets talk about simpler things. Well, relatively.

• Donating. Sugar or gold. This can be used two ways. (I thought as this much) Both related to guild levelling with these sugars and golds.

1. Basically, with this sugar and gold you level up your guild and this gives you perks. Not changing the match type but the reward type. You win more sugar/gold or a little change in infamy maybe(lets say level five guilds gives you 25 if you win) or decrasing the evolve many or traning time. Its like VIP perks I know. Some can be seperated and used in guilds maybe.
2. Well without others this wont have the real impact but increasing the guild member level. so like level 10 you have a guild member limit of 50.

• Guild leagues. This is basically the leagues we currently have but with guilds as you can understand. These will gave players something also like leagues.
• Part sharing. I dont think this will really gona happen or work because anyone still needs and whole evolving system based on luck and receiving another copy of work part by chance. Buy ı saw som people talking this in-game. So this is their idea.

So these are few simplier things may have done for guilds to become active in-game. Only thing useful from them is tags..
#MakeGuildsGreatAgain

 

Currently the only good use for a guild is easy fleet up duos, other than that I personally think they are useless.

 

Even for that most people using chat. I mean global one because you now if you use 'by request' recruitment system guild chat is only green same type or sentences with ** requested to join. *** cancelled...

 

Let me ask y'all a question:

Do you build a house starting with the walls? No.
Do you buy furniture before you have somewhere to live? No.
Do you buy a car without knowing how much your job will pay you? No.

So why on earth is there a problem with setting up guilds and building from there? This is a foundation and the details will come out later. If you don't want to be in a guild, then don't. Simple as that.

 

Agree. But odd they do not give any bonus of any kind. Strange oversight.

 

What the heck rxlgenerate. The game should at least have features with A GOOD PURPOSE for the player by the time of the global launch of the game. I mean, how could NOBODY in the dev team have thought of this when Clash Royale has been there for almost the same time as the beta has been around, and Royale has already implemented donations and such as a pvp game. Even Clash of clans has this for the past 3 years. What a half-baked game. I'm not playing until Rovio fixes all these dumb issues

 

I'm not saying it's perfect or that it compares to other games we all have played where guilds have a purpose. That's not the point I was trying to make. I get it...guilds should have a purpose...and I'm sure they'll get to that eventually. I agree, perks and donations and help are all reasons to be apart of a guild.
But let me stress...I'm truly with you on this topic. While I try to play devil's advocate sometimes...I am with you @Risu

 

Actually most of the features used in the game do have a good purpose right now, they wouldn't be there if they didn't.

 

Dude, Clash Royale JUST IMPLEMENTED guild battles earlier this year. Before that, the only purpose of a guild in CR was to donate cards...that's it. NO OTHER PURPOSE...
CoC...the only purpose of a guild there is to donate as well. Now, there are other games, Game of War and Mobile Strike where it's a little more prevalent with the perks...but truly think about those games!!! They don't have to account for PHYSICS and GRAPHICS.
Look, I'm advocating for this game because I like it. I'm not here to bash it nor am I here to back them for having a perfect product. If you don't like it, i'll see ya when you do like it.

 

Yeah I think we can all agree that they will not stay like this and more improtant they shouldnt but reason that why I created this topic is to learn any information from dev team about this subject. They have something in mind? or already doing it? Give us some round times as 1-2 months or 2-3 weeks.. Or they can say we expecting community feedback to make something. Wll, this is the feedback as you can write your own different ideas too, which I would glad to hear